Episode 8

full
Published on:

15th Jun 2023

Trip and Fall Accidents in New Jersey: A Case Study Uncovering Negligence and Liability

Episode 8 of Jersey Justice Podcast™: Trip and Fall Accidents in New Jersey: A Case Study Uncovering Negligence and Liability with Stephanie Tolnai, Esq.

Watch this episode on our YouTube channel to see clips of how our client fell down poorly marked stairs outside a New Jersey restaurant.

SUBSCRIBE AND WATCH ON YOUTUBE

Make sure to subscribe to our YouTube Channel https://www.youtube.com/@Clarklawnj

Watch the video of this podcast episode here: https://youtu.be/lDhdxe0Uk0c

SUBMIT YOUR QUESTIONS

Submit Your Podcast Questions If You Want Us to Answer Them on Our Show: questions@jerseyjusticepodcast.com

Subscribe to our podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. You can also visit our podcast website to listen to all of the latest episodes at: JerseyJusticePodcast.com 

Visit our Main Website for More Information About Clark Law Firm P.C. and our practice areas.

Call us at 1-877-841-8855 if you need legal assistance. 

CONNECT WITH CLARK LAW FIRM P.C. ON SOCIAL MEDIA 

Clark Law Firm P.C. on LinkedIn



Clark Law Firm P.C. on Facebook 


YOUTUBE 


Watch Jersey Justice Podcast on Our YouTube Channel


CONNECT WITH GERALD H. CLARK, ESQ.


Gerald H. Clark, Esq. on Twitter


Connect with Gerald on LinkedIn 


CONNECT WITH MARK W. MORRIS, ESQ. 


Connect with Mark W. Morris, Esq. on LinkedIn


Applying to Be a Guest on Our Show or Having Gerald and Mark as a Guest on Your Show


If you would like to be a guest on our show or have Gerald and Mark on your show or for media/press inquiries, contact Dimple at dimple@clarklawnj.com 


Submit Your Podcast Questions: questions@jerseyjusticepodcast.com

Podcast Producer

Podcast Produced by Dimple Dang, Legal Marketing Expert, and Podcaster 


The information shared on this podcast is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create and does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. This podcast is for informational purposes only.

Transcript
Speaker:

Welcome to Jersey Justice, a civil law podcast that shares

Speaker:

practical tips and stories about personal and workplace injuries.

Speaker:

Joined two of the brightest New Jersey injury attorneys, Gerald Clark

Speaker:

and Mark Morris of Clark Law Firm.

Speaker:

As they take you behind the scenes of.

Speaker:

Justice and civil law.

Speaker:

But first, a quick disclaimer.

Speaker:

The information shared on this podcast is for general information purposes only.

Speaker:

Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any

Speaker:

individual case or situation.

Speaker:

This information is not intended to create and does not constitute

Speaker:

an attorney-client relationship.

Speaker:

Welcome back to Jersey Justice, and today we are gonna be talking about slip and

Speaker:

fall injuries, and we're gonna be talking about how you can be more safe and what

Speaker:

you need to know about negligence on part of establishments and business owners.

Speaker:

And we're gonna get into what you really need to understand about slip

Speaker:

and fall injuries in New Jersey.

Speaker:

And today we are with Stephanie Tok because she is gonna be talking to

Speaker:

us about slip and fall injuries.

Speaker:

We wanna welcome Stephanie.

Speaker:

So Stephanie, welcome to the show.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

Glad to be here.

Speaker:

Stephanie, we're so excited to have you here today.

Speaker:

So for our audience, I'd love for you to share a little bit more about yourself.

Speaker:

It can be anything.

Speaker:

It can be about why you decided to become a lawyer or maybe you know,

Speaker:

what you like to do when you're not working in the field of law, and you

Speaker:

know, just any fun fact, anything you'd like to share with the audience.

Speaker:

Well, thank you.

Speaker:

I'm glad to be here today.

Speaker:

I have always wanted to be an attorney, even when I was younger.

Speaker:

I'm not sure of the exact reason why, but I, I always like the presenting

Speaker:

your case, arguing your opinion.

Speaker:

I used to do defense for a little bit, you know, 20 years ago.

Speaker:

And I didn't enjoy that as much because I didn't feel the one-on-one connection with

Speaker:

the client that I definitely feel now.

Speaker:

It's almost like a story, cuz I love to read too, and I feel

Speaker:

like a case is like a story.

Speaker:

It starts in the beginning how the incident happened, how the crash or the

Speaker:

slip and fall or whatever it is, and how it has impacted that person's life.

Speaker:

And then the ending is, If I'm successful or our attorneys at our firm

Speaker:

are successful, which we frequently are, and most likely are, then they

Speaker:

have a good ending to their story.

Speaker:

So the connection that we get with our clients is amazing.

Speaker:

Our firm, I've had many clients after I'm done representing them,

Speaker:

say I've never had that connection before, and that they appreciated

Speaker:

it and they get immediate responses.

Speaker:

And that's something I feel that I pride myself in.

Speaker:

And I feel like that it benefits the clients.

Speaker:

Things I love to do.

Speaker:

I love to travel.

Speaker:

I travel with my family.

Speaker:

I travel with my two kids who are older and we go everywhere

Speaker:

from Europe to Colorado to, so that, that's one thing I enjoy.

Speaker:

Awesome.

Speaker:

Awesome.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for sharing that with us.

Speaker:

I love that you love to travel.

Speaker:

That's so much fun.

Speaker:

And yes, that personal connection is so important and when we're

Speaker:

dealing with people, we're dealing with their lives and livelihood.

Speaker:

That's really commendable.

Speaker:

So thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

So, you know, today, Stephanie, we're we're talking about

Speaker:

slip and fall injuries.

Speaker:

I know that you've handled a lot of slip and fall cases at the firm, and first

Speaker:

of all, maybe for our audience, you can share with us when it comes to slip and

Speaker:

fall, like, you know, What's defined as a slip and fall or slip and trip or, you

Speaker:

know, are there any slang, terminology, words that, that are used in New Jersey as

Speaker:

well to describe these type of injuries?

Speaker:

Well, I mean, there's numerous examples of slip and fall.

Speaker:

You could have, it could be on ice, it could be outside of a big box

Speaker:

store that perhaps, you know where the loading zone is and somebody drops

Speaker:

something off the back of the truck.

Speaker:

It could be some sort of material that, that the person doesn't even know.

Speaker:

It could be at a restaurant with spilled something.

Speaker:

It could be you're walking on a sidewalk on your way to the bus and there's a

Speaker:

differential in the sidewalk or a pot, you know, a pothole in the street.

Speaker:

And you happen to step on that.

Speaker:

So there's many instances of what a slip and fall could be.

Speaker:

It's interesting you say that about whether it's a slip and fall or a

Speaker:

trip and fall, and there's times where you do need to be very careful of

Speaker:

how you phrase it, because sometimes if you say trip and fall, it makes,

Speaker:

it seems like it was the customer or the client's fault for tripping on

Speaker:

something, when in fact it was, you know, something was left out in the walkway

Speaker:

or something was left out in the area.

Speaker:

So, That's one thing to keep in mind.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for sharing that because I'm just getting this vision

Speaker:

of someone at a grocery store and there could be a box or something sticking

Speaker:

out of the aisle and they don't see that and they trip over it and they fall.

Speaker:

I mean, obviously that's not really their fault because they didn't see it and there

Speaker:

were no safety cones like preventing that.

Speaker:

So thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

So Jerry, I wanna get your perspective on this.

Speaker:

When it comes to slip and fall injuries in New Jersey, what's one

Speaker:

of the most important things that the public needs to know about?

Speaker:

Slip and fall injuries specifically in the state of New Jersey?

Speaker:

Well, the first thing I would say, you know, you say, oh, slip and fall injuries.

Speaker:

The first thing that comes to mind to me is like ambulance chasing

Speaker:

lawyer, and, oh, he slipped on a banana peel and let's sue someone.

Speaker:

So I actually don't like, To refer to them as slip and fall injuries, just cuz

Speaker:

there's like a bad connotation about that.

Speaker:

I like to refer them more as like fall down injuries, that kind of thing.

Speaker:

So the big picture, like kind of the big picture about that is that

Speaker:

there are all kinds of building codes and construction codes.

Speaker:

In essence, they are basic safety rules that are designed to keep everyone safe.

Speaker:

So if you walk.

Speaker:

Upstairs, like the height of the stairs has to be the same.

Speaker:

You can't have one stair riser being, you know, a certain amount of inches.

Speaker:

And then the next double and then the platform, the step that you step

Speaker:

on has to be a certain width and it has to be uniform and there has to be

Speaker:

handrails and all that thing, and the handrails have to go to a certain way

Speaker:

that's natural with the way you walk.

Speaker:

So that where you would naturally put your hand down.

Speaker:

You wouldn't miss the stairwell and fall.

Speaker:

So there's all kinds of building codes and basic safety rules that are in place

Speaker:

to prevent disaster happening to people.

Speaker:

I've had fall down cases where there's like skull fractures.

Speaker:

A person's gone blind.

Speaker:

We've had, we have had many fall down cases where there are serious broken

Speaker:

bones, which required surgery and.

Speaker:

Rods and screws put in and in almost every case that I've had in that

Speaker:

regard, there was a decision made by like a property owner or a business

Speaker:

to just disregard basic safety rules.

Speaker:

Whether it is a stairwell that is not up to code or a restaurant or a big chain

Speaker:

supermarket where there's a spilled something on the floor, which is a hazard.

Speaker:

And it's funny because like when you're younger, You know, oh,

Speaker:

you fall down, it's no big deal.

Speaker:

You look at the nfl, the guys are jumping and falling all over the place,

Speaker:

but those are young, young people.

Speaker:

But when you get older, A simple fall down can wreck the rest of your life.

Speaker:

We've seen it many, many times, and again, it's ordinarily because there's

Speaker:

a basic set of safety rules that have been ignored, and often we find they're

Speaker:

ignored because a business may wanna like maximize profits and not spend the

Speaker:

money or the effort that it takes to clean up a mess or to make an area safe.

Speaker:

You know, for example, like you said, something's sticking in

Speaker:

an aisle and it's funny because.

Speaker:

Like I've been to other countries where either they don't have

Speaker:

building codes or, or they don't have like a personal injury system.

Speaker:

Like for example, I've been to Mexico and it's very, very hard to bring a personal

Speaker:

injury case in Mexico as I understand it.

Speaker:

I mean, I don't practice in Mexico.

Speaker:

I don't know for sure.

Speaker:

But from speaking with attorneys in Mexico and everything, they don't,

Speaker:

they don't really enforce building codes in many, in many instances.

Speaker:

So when you walk in another country, You're used to walking in the United

Speaker:

States and you're, you're used to just the stairs being even, and the handrail being

Speaker:

where it should be, and you know, they're not being big craters in the sidewalk.

Speaker:

So when you go to another country, you gotta be very careful because

Speaker:

they don't have these building codes and they don't have.

Speaker:

Law where if you get hurt, you can actually go to an attorney

Speaker:

on a contingency basis where you can bring a case and, and

Speaker:

don't have to pay an attorney fee unless, unless there's a recovery.

Speaker:

So I think the biggest thing for kind of the public to know about fall down

Speaker:

cases, Is that there's basic set of safety rules that have to be followed, and if

Speaker:

they're not followed, disaster can happen.

Speaker:

And if that happens and you go to a law firm or an attorney that's

Speaker:

experienced in that can help you out.

Speaker:

You know, because we've had people that can't feed their families, they can't

Speaker:

work because they, they get hurt falling down spinal injuries and the like.

Speaker:

Yeah, I mean a lot of those injuries can be quite serious and it can

Speaker:

take, you know, months and months of recovering and physical therapy

Speaker:

and a lot of things are involved.

Speaker:

So thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

I wanna go back over to Stephanie.

Speaker:

And Stephanie.

Speaker:

I wanted to know from you, can you think of a case that you've handled at the firm

Speaker:

that had to do with the slip and fall?

Speaker:

Maybe give us a little bit of details, some background history of why the

Speaker:

person fell, what caused the fall, what their injuries were, and, and

Speaker:

how the, that case was handled.

Speaker:

Sure I had a recent case and it involved woman, she was probably in

Speaker:

her seventies, and it kind of goes along with Jerry's point of, you know,

Speaker:

when you're younger and you fracture something, you can recover a lot easier.

Speaker:

But when these, a lot of our older clients.

Speaker:

Suffer an injury, it, it's hard for them.

Speaker:

And then what happens is in this situation, the woman was going

Speaker:

with her family to a restaurant to have something to eat.

Speaker:

And it was dark.

Speaker:

It was in November, end of November, and the facility had a big Christmas tree out

Speaker:

in front of the door and it wasn't lit.

Speaker:

And they decided, and this is ignoring the, a basic safety rule, they decided

Speaker:

the restaurant as well as the Christmas tree company that put the tree up.

Speaker:

To remove a paver from the walkway, and they thought that it would be a

Speaker:

good idea to stake the missing paver with a wire to cross it across the

Speaker:

walkway and attach it to the tree.

Speaker:

So my client comes walking up, it's dark.

Speaker:

The tree's not lit.

Speaker:

It was dark outside the restaurant too, and her foot not only gets

Speaker:

stuck in the missing paver, but then she trips over the wire.

Speaker:

So in that case, she had a broken femur, which is right above her

Speaker:

kneecap, and she had to have surgery.

Speaker:

And actually then maybe about five to six months later, she had to have

Speaker:

surgery to have the hardware removed because she had some plates and screws

Speaker:

in there and they were really bothering when she was trying to do her pt.

Speaker:

So then she had another surgery.

Speaker:

She had to have that all removed.

Speaker:

So that was a situation where, you know, we got an expert report to say that

Speaker:

clearly that both the restaurant and the.

Speaker:

Christmas Tree Company violated basic safety rules and then, you know, we were

Speaker:

able to get very good recovery for her.

Speaker:

I think I kind of remember that case.

Speaker:

And what was the wire like?

Speaker:

Could you see it?

Speaker:

I mean, it almost sounds like a trip wire unlike, you know,

Speaker:

like, almost like a trip wire.

Speaker:

Like what was that wire like?

Speaker:

Do you remember?

Speaker:

That's exactly what it was.

Speaker:

Like.

Speaker:

It was a, it was, it was gray, so, and it was a hard stiff wire.

Speaker:

And the problem was that they, they staked it from the missing

Speaker:

paver all the way across the wall.

Speaker:

Not a huge cross the walkway, but a good distance where, and she couldn't see it,

Speaker:

so that's why she tripped right over it.

Speaker:

They didn't put any flags or anything hanging down on the wire.

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

There were no flags.

Speaker:

And what's interesting is after the incident, after she was tripped on

Speaker:

it and was severely injured, then they decided to put the stations,

Speaker:

you know, like you see at a movie theater with the that around it.

Speaker:

Then they decided to put that around it.

Speaker:

So then the patrons, no, no one else would be hurt.

Speaker:

But that was a little too late for this particular, you know,

Speaker:

individual who did get injured.

Speaker:

So that's clearly they were negligent.

Speaker:

Do you know if they put that up to protect other people?

Speaker:

Did they do it right after she fell or after our law firm got

Speaker:

involved and sent a letter?

Speaker:

No, they did it after she fell.

Speaker:

They did it after she fell.

Speaker:

And actually there were emails between the restaurant and the.

Speaker:

And the Christmas tree company the next morning and the restaurant

Speaker:

said, Hey, why did you put the Christmas tree up like this?

Speaker:

It's a danger to our patrons.

Speaker:

And you know, you never did it like this before.

Speaker:

So one would think that, oh, it's just a Christmas tree company that is on

Speaker:

the hook because they didn't do the correct implementation of, of the tree.

Speaker:

But the thing with that is it's the restaurant that hired

Speaker:

the Christmas tree company.

Speaker:

So that restaurant has a duty of care to its business invitees,

Speaker:

which is what it somebody that's coming to the restaurant is called.

Speaker:

They have a duty of care to them.

Speaker:

So they both violated their safety rules.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

I mean, of course, but that's why we have, we need lawyers because

Speaker:

things like that happen all the time.

Speaker:

So when it comes to slip and fall injuries and you're thinking about.

Speaker:

Everywhere, like establishments, like in New Jersey, I mean, people are just

Speaker:

going out, you know, for a nice meal.

Speaker:

They're going to a restaurant, they're going to a concert or a

Speaker:

show, they're going to all these different places and venues.

Speaker:

They may not even be aware of the dangers.

Speaker:

The sidewalk might not be even at these places.

Speaker:

There might be, you know, objects that are on the floor that were not.

Speaker:

Noticed and, and cleaned up, there might be spilled beverages

Speaker:

that make the floor slippery.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

So can we talk a little bit about the responsibility of these establishments to

Speaker:

make sure that they have an environment that is safe for the patrons that, you

Speaker:

know, frequent these establishments?

Speaker:

I can respond to something and, and, and it was one of the things that I wanted to

Speaker:

point out earlier that sometimes I think.

Speaker:

Somebody that, that isn't familiar with the law may think, well, I fell in, I'm

Speaker:

not gonna say a store, but you know, the big stores, the stores that we go

Speaker:

to, I fell something was on the floor.

Speaker:

That store is automatically responsible.

Speaker:

But the, the way the law is, the defendants have to have notice

Speaker:

and knowledge of that condition.

Speaker:

Meaning notice the knowledge that.

Speaker:

There was a lemonade in the middle of the, the store that you were

Speaker:

shopping in to get your, your tissues.

Speaker:

Now there's sometimes where you can get around that notice of knowledge,

Speaker:

which one of the situations is if the.

Speaker:

Defendant, the store or the business owner created that condition.

Speaker:

So for instance, you had given an example before if there was a box in the aisle.

Speaker:

So if the store actually put a box in the store, employees actually put a box in the

Speaker:

aisle, or the store employees were packing something up and they left it all in the

Speaker:

middle of the floor, then we wouldn't have to prove notice of knowledge because

Speaker:

that defendant created that condition.

Speaker:

And it's the same thing with what's called like a mode of operation.

Speaker:

So if you have a, you know, the self-serve big box stores where you're

Speaker:

loading all your stuff up in the front, or you have some of the grocery stores

Speaker:

where you know it, perhaps it's not in the bag at that point, and they're

Speaker:

bagging it, and so something happens there, then you all, then you don't

Speaker:

have to show that the defendant had noticed a knowledge of that condition.

Speaker:

Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for sharing about notice and knowledge.

Speaker:

So I think that's a concept that our audience needs to know about.

Speaker:

So, Jerry, what else does the audience need to know about slip and fall injuries?

Speaker:

And, and maybe you can talk a little bit about like the investigation process.

Speaker:

So if someone does come to our firm, what are some of the steps involved

Speaker:

in really, you know, investigating their injury and proving that there

Speaker:

was negligence, because that's a whole process that we have to take them through.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think if someone comes to us for, say, a fall down injury,

Speaker:

uh, let's say it's at a restaurant.

Speaker:

And to answer your question very simply, the idea is that because these

Speaker:

businesses are inviting people to the business to make money, that they have a

Speaker:

duty to make the place safe for people.

Speaker:

You can't invite people in into a trap.

Speaker:

So if someone comes to us and, and they have fallen, every case is

Speaker:

different and the steps that are taken in each case is different.

Speaker:

But generally speaking, we're gonna try to contact the establishment as

Speaker:

soon as possible and see if there's any surveillance videos of the incident.

Speaker:

That's always really important.

Speaker:

Today, many places are covered by surveillance videos,

Speaker:

so we'll try to get that.

Speaker:

A lot of times we'll get pictures, we'll try to get pictures, and

Speaker:

we'll go to the scene and do like an inspection or investigation.

Speaker:

Sometimes we'll go there with an engineer, so like if someone fell down steps,

Speaker:

we don't necessarily know if there's anything wrong with the steps until.

Speaker:

We have an engineer look at it or get some good pictures of the situation.

Speaker:

So, so that's it.

Speaker:

So Stephanie told about a case, so I, I gotta do a little bit of a, a war story.

Speaker:

We call 'em war stories sometimes.

Speaker:

Like, ah, this is what happened, you know, so we had a case and

Speaker:

to share a little video here.

Speaker:

And so this nice woman was walking out of a restaurant and this

Speaker:

video is about 30 seconds long.

Speaker:

And she's there with her friend and this restaurant did serve alcohol and

Speaker:

no, she was not under the influence of alcohol walking out of there.

Speaker:

And she goes to step and falls down.

Speaker:

It's, it's always hard looking at that video because it's like kind of traumatic.

Speaker:

So, so when you go here and look, it's like, it's like what happened?

Speaker:

So we did investigation.

Speaker:

We went there and we got a picture of the steps, and it was really wacky and dimple.

Speaker:

I have a question for you.

Speaker:

You see this picture all right now, where do you think the top platform

Speaker:

ends and the first step starts?

Speaker:

Can you tell.

Speaker:

I'm gonna be honest with you.

Speaker:

It's really hard to tell.

Speaker:

It almost looks like an optical illusion, in my opinion.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

That's funny you say that.

Speaker:

So when we looked at this, it looks like the first yellow strip here is

Speaker:

on the platform at the top platform.

Speaker:

Do you see that?

Speaker:

Do you, do you see the first yellow strip here?

Speaker:

Oh wow.

Speaker:

You know what?

Speaker:

You're right.

Speaker:

It does.

Speaker:

That's exactly what it looks like.

Speaker:

Doesn't it look like it's on the top of the platform?

Speaker:

That's very deceptive.

Speaker:

Yes, and that's exactly what happened here.

Speaker:

So as she's walking out, it looks like this.

Speaker:

Now, where that yellow strip is, there's actually a, it's a step down,

Speaker:

but from what you called it an optical illusion, which is what our expert

Speaker:

called it in the case, it looks like she's still walking on the same step,

Speaker:

and that's why she mistepped and fell.

Speaker:

So, That's one of the most common causes of falling is when you miss a

Speaker:

step because you don't see the step.

Speaker:

And in this video clearly it's very difficult to see the step

Speaker:

because where the yellow line is, I mean, it's like deceptive.

Speaker:

You know?

Speaker:

Imagine if it was an older person who had a bit of cataracts,

Speaker:

that would be even worse.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So you could see she's going to step and if, I don't know

Speaker:

how much you can see it there.

Speaker:

But you could see the edge of this top of the platform.

Speaker:

And her heel is like right in the middle of it.

Speaker:

She's thinking she's still on the top platform and goes down, so,

Speaker:

so if we look at a closeup picture of that and you could see it.

Speaker:

Look at this one.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

So we had an expert look at that to give you an idea of what these cases are like.

Speaker:

And lo and behold, there's a building code that addresses this exactly.

Speaker:

And these yellow stripes on the steps are called treatment.

Speaker:

They're called step treatments.

Speaker:

And if you decide to treat the, first of all, you have to put treatment on it,

Speaker:

meaning you have to put the yellow strip because this wood all looks the same.

Speaker:

So you have to have a treatment to differentiate it.

Speaker:

But when you do the treatment, the building code requires the treatment

Speaker:

also to be on the top step for this very thing that happened here.

Speaker:

So we investigated the case.

Speaker:

We attempted to settle the case pre-suit.

Speaker:

They weren't offering any, any reasonable money.

Speaker:

We got experts in the case and then the insurance company.

Speaker:

So in all these cases, pretty much all these cases, there's an insurance

Speaker:

company behind the restaurant.

Speaker:

When you file the case, yes, you name the restaurant, but really it's the

Speaker:

insurance company that would hire the lawyers for the restaurant and

Speaker:

pay any judgment or settlement to the limits of the insurance policy.

Speaker:

So really it's the insurance company that you're fighting with.

Speaker:

So then they hire these experts that said, oh, it, you don't need a treatment

Speaker:

on the top of the step, and it would've made it more dangerous, et cetera, et

Speaker:

cetera, and that shouldn't be done.

Speaker:

So then in the case, after we got those reports and after they got the

Speaker:

report from our expert that did this and laid it out, we went back to the

Speaker:

scene and lo and behold, they put a treatment on the top of the step.

Speaker:

So they're basically hiring these experts to basically just lie.

Speaker:

And it's like, oh, you know, so what happened?

Speaker:

So here, there was a bunch of injuries, but one of the more significant injuries

Speaker:

was she broke her wrist real bad.

Speaker:

You can see the deformity there.

Speaker:

And then she had to go to the, to the er, and they put her hand up in the

Speaker:

sling and did like a closed reduction.

Speaker:

And then what we'll also do from time to time in cases, is

Speaker:

we'll get medical illustrations.

Speaker:

So this is a, this is a medical illustration of the, the actual

Speaker:

x-ray, and then it's drawn to show what happened to the bones, and then

Speaker:

there's like plates put in and all this kind of thing, you know, and

Speaker:

then there was like other injuries.

Speaker:

So that's kind of like an example of one of these cases.

Speaker:

And.

Speaker:

I mean, a person like that, they could have broke their neck.

Speaker:

It could have been an older woman.

Speaker:

I mean, this woman had probably $200,000 in medical bills from this.

Speaker:

It's not like you do it and then, oh, the insurance company pays the money.

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

What they do, because these insurance companies are funded

Speaker:

like to billions of dollars.

Speaker:

And they used that money to just fight and try to wear you down.

Speaker:

We took this case, I think we litigated for like four years, um, and we

Speaker:

brought it all the way to trial.

Speaker:

We were in the middle of jury selection and then finally they paid, I forget

Speaker:

the exact number, it was like got the woman like six or $700,000 and

Speaker:

settlement, but it wasn't easy.

Speaker:

It was like a lot of work.

Speaker:

And then they send her to doctors saying that, oh, her injuries aren't

Speaker:

bad, and she had a good result.

Speaker:

She also had some spinal injuries and they say, oh, well, She

Speaker:

doesn't have spinal injuries.

Speaker:

And even if she does, that's from being a cheerleader in high

Speaker:

school or something, and they come up with all these crazy things.

Speaker:

So that's what we have to fight.

Speaker:

So, so again, you gotta be careful out there if you're, if you know,

Speaker:

if you're running a business and stuff, make sure you get your general

Speaker:

liability insurance and make sure you're following just basic safety rules.

Speaker:

And a lot of these safety rules are just common sense, you know, Jared,

Speaker:

like that's such a great example.

Speaker:

And I mean, what's coming to my mind is, I'm pretty sure.

Speaker:

That's not the first time that someone has fallen down that staircase.

Speaker:

It's just that that's the first time someone's fallen down and injured

Speaker:

themselves or injured themselves enough where you know they broke

Speaker:

their wrist and things like that.

Speaker:

But I can guarantee someone's probably fallen down unless it was newly built and

Speaker:

that she's one of the first few people.

Speaker:

The other thing that comes to mind is, When things like this happen,

Speaker:

I think clients are not aware.

Speaker:

Like they just think like the restaurant's gonna say, oh yeah, I

Speaker:

can deal with our insurance agency.

Speaker:

And they're not really clear about why it's so important to hire a reputable and

Speaker:

knowledgeable personal injury attorney to fight for them because maybe you can

Speaker:

shed a little bit of light on what happens when they don't have an attorney to

Speaker:

represent them, and they're just trying to deal with the insurance company and

Speaker:

the restaurant on their own, for example.

Speaker:

Yeah, just real quick on that and then maybe Stephanie can speak to that, but

Speaker:

I, I had a quick thing just in what you said, well, maybe they didn't get hurt

Speaker:

or maybe they, the other maybe is, you know, if there was other people that

Speaker:

fell is maybe they didn't find a lawyer that knows how to handle these cases.

Speaker:

We've had many cases come to us that we have settled for many hundreds of

Speaker:

thousands or sometimes millions of dollars, where other attorneys either

Speaker:

told them you don't have a case, or they handled the case for a while.

Speaker:

I just settled the case last Friday.

Speaker:

It was for a worker who fell off scaffolding on a job and he had built the

Speaker:

scaffolding and it didn't work, and he had to like kind of go off the scaffolding.

Speaker:

We settled this case for $400,000 and that again, it was after like five years

Speaker:

of litigation, but he was so happy.

Speaker:

He goes, you know, I went to this other law firm.

Speaker:

And they told me I had no case and I couldn't handle it.

Speaker:

And that wasn't like a real estate law firm or a criminal defense law firm.

Speaker:

It was a personal injury law firm.

Speaker:

So it's important to actually find a law firm that handles the cases

Speaker:

that have a reputation of taking cases to trial, that kind of thing.

Speaker:

But Stephanie can probably speak a little bit better about what, specifically

Speaker:

what, what you had asked about.

Speaker:

Can someone handle these cases on their own and get justice?

Speaker:

So I think the answer to that is somebody could handle it on their own, but they

Speaker:

certainly will not get the amount of money and the compensation that they would

Speaker:

get if they hired a well-versed personal injury law firm like ours, or really

Speaker:

any firm that knows what they're doing.

Speaker:

Cuz the thing is, the insurance company will say to them, oh,

Speaker:

here's, you know, Here's $3,000 or $5,000 to keep them quiet.

Speaker:

And to a client that might be like, Ooh, okay, that's good.

Speaker:

But the thing is, when they come to us, then we say, okay, we, we get the video.

Speaker:

We see if there were any prior incidents there.

Speaker:

And then once we get involved, the insurance company, they kind of sit up

Speaker:

and take notice and say, okay, wait.

Speaker:

This is a serious case.

Speaker:

So I definitely think if you wanna get the most for your money and be compensated

Speaker:

for a safety violation that the store or the restaurant has committed, then

Speaker:

I definitely think you need to come to our law firm or an experienced attorney.

Speaker:

Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker:

That's, that's, you know, really, really crucial because without that,

Speaker:

they're just gonna be misled and they may not know what they don't know.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

It's not their fault for not knowing.

Speaker:

And I think that's one of the reasons why we're, you know, putting this podcast

Speaker:

out there is to educate New Jersey workers and residents on knowing the

Speaker:

difference between the laws and getting the justice that they need because

Speaker:

they don't know what they don't know.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And we're doing this to.

Speaker:

Bring more awareness around injuries, whether it's workplace

Speaker:

injuries, whether it's construction injuries, whether it's slip and fall

Speaker:

injuries, like all of those things.

Speaker:

So thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

And then one of my final questions would be like Jerry, And then maybe if

Speaker:

you know you wanna chime in after that, Stephanie as well, that'd be great.

Speaker:

But I know like people always wanna know this like, well, how,

Speaker:

how are settlements calculated?

Speaker:

And I know there's 10 tons of factors that go into calculating a settlement,

Speaker:

but for the people that are always asking these questions, maybe you

Speaker:

could shed a little bit more light onto that topic, because I know it's

Speaker:

a common question that people have.

Speaker:

All right, so I'll equate that to a hamburger or a cheeseburger.

Speaker:

How is a cheeseburger priced?

Speaker:

Well, if you go to McDonald's, the cheeseburger is gonna be priced one way.

Speaker:

If you go to Spark Steakhouse in New York City, the cheeseburger is

Speaker:

gonna be priced a different way, and a lot of that goes into how

Speaker:

many cheeseburgers are they making?

Speaker:

What kind of meat are they getting?

Speaker:

So at the end of the day, you know, law is a business, law firms, private

Speaker:

law firms, personal injury law firms.

Speaker:

It is a business and there's, and there's different business models.

Speaker:

And some law firms will go for like kind of the fast food law, meaning they'll

Speaker:

make a ton of hamburgers and charge $2 for the hamburger, or maybe perhaps on

Speaker:

one menu you can get it for a dollar.

Speaker:

Whereas a steakhouse is gonna charge a lot more because it's a better hamburger.

Speaker:

So, Settlements are calculated on a lot of different things.

Speaker:

There's never a guarantee in any of these cases, and we've definitely lost cases.

Speaker:

There's no question about that.

Speaker:

But we've also won a lot of cases, and we've certainly won

Speaker:

far more than we have lost.

Speaker:

And we like to think that we get really good settlements and we

Speaker:

get high settlements in cases because we we're not a mill.

Speaker:

We don't handle big volumes of cases, and I like to think that we have a reputation

Speaker:

for taking cases to verdict and trying them and hiring good experts and putting

Speaker:

the resources and the tender loving care that these cases require we put into them.

Speaker:

And I like to think that because of that we're making.

Speaker:

A better hamburger, but we're we're getting better settlements.

Speaker:

So there's a lot that goes into how do you value a case and

Speaker:

how do you value a settlement.

Speaker:

It's the injury, but it's the attorney and the law firm and how they're working

Speaker:

the case up and are they investigating it.

Speaker:

Like those medical illustrations that I showed you on that case, I

Speaker:

think they cost probably $8,000.

Speaker:

Some law firms.

Speaker:

Won't even think to do medical illustrations like that.

Speaker:

They'll just say, oh yeah, they broke the wrist and had surgery.

Speaker:

It's one thing to say, it's another thing to show it.

Speaker:

A lot of it goes into like the age of the person and what permanent life

Speaker:

changes they've had and what the medical bills are and what the wages are.

Speaker:

But it's easy to say all those things, but it's another thing to go up against

Speaker:

a well-funded insurance company or a corporation that's fighting you in court

Speaker:

and fighting everything you do, including fighting your ability to make the claim

Speaker:

for medical bills, fighting your ability to make a claim for wages or fighting,

Speaker:

your ability to bring in witnesses to testify as to what the injuries are.

Speaker:

So a lot goes into how it's valued.

Speaker:

So thanks for asking that.

Speaker:

Yeah, thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

I mean, and then that was a great analogy, by the way.

Speaker:

Thank people can relate to storytelling and hamburgers and all that stuff,

Speaker:

so thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

You know, last thoughts are like, let's, let's see if we can leave the

Speaker:

audience with some pointers on their day-to-day life and errands that

Speaker:

they're running out in New Jersey.

Speaker:

Like what are some tips you can give them on staying safe and being

Speaker:

more aware of their surroundings so that they are not ending up

Speaker:

in one of these slip and fall or.

Speaker:

Fall down injuries, as you would say.

Speaker:

I think a few tips that I would have is just one of the things that you said is

Speaker:

being more aware of your surroundings.

Speaker:

So when you park in the parking lot at the, at the mall or one of the

Speaker:

big box stores and you get out, think to yourself, okay, am I getting out?

Speaker:

And especially if there's ice or there's snowy conditions, don't assume, never

Speaker:

assume that it's properly cleared.

Speaker:

Never assume that there it was properly salted or that there isn't ice somewhere.

Speaker:

So just I, I would say as to that, take your time, be very mindful of your

Speaker:

surroundings when you're in a store.

Speaker:

The same thing, be mindful of your surroundings.

Speaker:

Don't assume that it, the stores are gonna be, the aisles are gonna be

Speaker:

clean and neat and there's not gonna be something that's, that's there.

Speaker:

But one of the things I wanted to bring up was, Also don't assume because

Speaker:

it's not gonna happen, that if you do fall, that that store is gonna

Speaker:

have your best interest at heart.

Speaker:

So for instance, if you're too injured, you call somebody and have them come,

Speaker:

you know, come out to file an incident report to say, Hey, you, you need to

Speaker:

save whatever video you have here.

Speaker:

Because you can't trust that they will have your interest

Speaker:

at heart because they won't.

Speaker:

And also, say for instance, you fell outside on a sidewalk at

Speaker:

your condominium complex, okay?

Speaker:

You might be thinking, oh gosh, I'm, I'm injured, I gotta get,

Speaker:

I gotta get to the hospital.

Speaker:

I got to get, get this figured out.

Speaker:

And that's true, but you can also have maybe somebody in your family say, Hey.

Speaker:

Any ring doorbells, we have an issue, one of my cases where there's, she

Speaker:

fell outside on her condominium.

Speaker:

They didn't properly clear it.

Speaker:

There was snow and there was ice.

Speaker:

And it was at a time when they, they knew the condominium owners

Speaker:

would be out walking their dogs and going to work and it wasn't cleared.

Speaker:

And they ended up getting a ring doorbell from somebody, one of their neighbors,

Speaker:

that showed exactly what happened.

Speaker:

So I guess my point is, if this does happen to you, just

Speaker:

really try to be proactive.

Speaker:

Don't wait.

Speaker:

And I know we're not on this, but same thing with an automobile accident.

Speaker:

I mean, you or automobile crash you.

Speaker:

Same thing.

Speaker:

We just had one where I'd hit by a car.

Speaker:

She was walking, she was a pedestrian.

Speaker:

And I said to the daughter when she called me, Hey, go to, there's a gas

Speaker:

station across the road, isn't there?

Speaker:

Let's get that video.

Speaker:

And they've got the video and it captured everything.

Speaker:

You wait too long and then the video will be erased.

Speaker:

So I guess that's what I would say to keep your eyes and your ears open,

Speaker:

and if something, God forbid happens, please be your own advocate and see if

Speaker:

you can get video and then, Come to us.

Speaker:

Thank you, Stephanie.

Speaker:

Those are all great tips and you know, actionable things that injured parties can

Speaker:

start taking or anyone who's with them can also help them do some of those things.

Speaker:

So thank you so much.

Speaker:

And, and Jerry, what else would you add to that in terms of any safety

Speaker:

pointers and tips for all of our New Jersey residents out there?

Speaker:

Well, I know that when I watch podcasts, I definitely lose interest after 20

Speaker:

minutes, and I know we're over that part.

Speaker:

So my advice would be to tune into the next podcast.

Speaker:

You're so smooth, aren't you?

Speaker:

But I'm also gonna tell the audience if they are listening to the audio

Speaker:

version right now, that we're gonna link the YouTube video in the show

Speaker:

notes and make sure you check that out to see the video of the case that

Speaker:

Jerry shared where the female fell with the poorly marked staircase.

Speaker:

I think you'll find it very fascinating to watch.

Speaker:

So make sure you guys do that.

Speaker:

And this is a wrap.

Speaker:

We'll see you guys next time.

Speaker:

And there you have it, folks.

Speaker:

Another episode of Jersey Justice Podcast.

Speaker:

If you're loving what you're hearing, it's time to head that subscribe button

Speaker:

on Apple, YouTube and Spotify podcast.

Speaker:

And don't forget to leave us a review online, share this podcast with your

Speaker:

friends and become their legal hero.

Speaker:

Dive into more episodes@jerseyjusticepodcast.com,

Speaker:

r clark law nj.com, and check out our show notes for more information.

Speaker:

If you're navigating legal issues, an need a guiding light,

Speaker:

we're just a phone call away.

Speaker:

Call us at +1 877-841-8855.

Speaker:

Again, 1 8 7 7 8 4 1 8 8 5 5.

Speaker:

Until next time, Jersey Justice Warriors stay empowered and informed.

Listen for free

Show artwork for Jersey Justice

About the Podcast

Jersey Justice
A Civil Law Podcast
Jersey Justice delivers insightful and engaging discussions on a range of civil law and policy matters in New Jersey, including workplace and construction site injuries, automobile crashes, commercial litigation, and other related legal matters. Jersey Justice is designed to keep listeners informed and educated about the complexities of civil law and policy in America.

Jersey Justice: A Civil Law Podcast is hosted by esteemed attorneys Gerald H. Clark and Mark W. Morris and delivers captivating and informative content through an interview-driven format, enriched with panel discussions that showcase the expertise of distinguished guest speakers from the legal field. The podcast is produced by Dimple Dang, Podcaster and Legal Marketing Expert.

About your hosts

Gerald Clark

Profile picture for Gerald Clark
Gerald H. Clark, Esq. is certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Civil Trial Attorney and holds a distinction shared by less than 3% of New Jersey attorneys.

Gerald H. Clark, an accomplished and influential attorney in New Jersey's construction injury law, has made significant strides in the legal field. A long-time member of the Board of Governors of the New Jersey Association for Justice, he has served as counsel on numerous state and national class action matters, including a landmark consumer fraud lawsuit against Cooper Tire & Rubber Company, which resulted in a settlement valued at $1-3 billion.

Throughout his career, Gerald has successfully handled catastrophic loss and wrongful death cases, passionately representing deserving clients on a contingency basis to ensure access to justice. His strategic appeals in cases like Costa v. Gaccione and Fernandes v. DAR Development Corp. have influenced New Jersey's construction injury law for the benefit of workers.

Gerald has been recognized in the New Jersey Law Journal's "40 Under 40" and named a "Rising Stars Super Lawyer" from 2006-2012. Since 2013, he has been consistently honored as a "Super Lawyer" by Thompson Reuters, a "Top 100 Trial Lawyer" by the National Trial Lawyers Association, and a "Top 100 Litigation Lawyer in the State of New Jersey" by the American Society of Legal Advocates.

Mark Morris

Profile picture for Mark Morris
Mark W. Morris, a senior trial attorney, has been recognized on the Super Lawyers Rising Stars List each year since 2019 and has been named a “Top 40 Under 40 Civil Plaintiff Trial Lawyer” by the National Trial Lawyers Organization since 2019 as well.

Throughout his career, Mark has obtained remarkable settlements and verdicts for his clients, such as a $2 million settlement for a concert patron injured by a stage diver, a $1.325 million settlement for a motorist struck by an intoxicated driver, a $1 million settlement in a negligent security case and a $975,000 settlement in a worksite products liability case. Additionally, he has played a vital role in helping Clark Law Firm P.C. achieve numerous multi-million-dollar settlements and jury verdicts including a jury verdict of $2,579,000 for a construction worker who was injured when he was backed over by a utility truck.

Leading the firm's Consumer Rights Division, Mark has successfully prosecuted state and nationwide consumer class action claims, representing clients against businesses engaging in misleading or fraudulent practices. Notably, he worked on an obsolete motor oil class action that resulted in a $28.5 million settlement for consumers in 2021. Mark has also secured a $1 million consumer fraud class action settlement involving misleading business practices related to the service of process.

With a commitment to all aspects of litigation, Mark has demonstrated success in handling client intake, depositions, motion practice, arbitrations, mediations, and trial. He has won several cases before the Appellate Division and has litigated in both state and federal courts throughout New Jersey and the Southern District of New York.