Speaker: 00:00:01

Welcome to Jersey Justice, a

civil law podcast that shares

2

: 00:00:04

practical tips and stories about

personal and workplace injuries.

3

: 00:00:08

Join two of the brightest New Jersey

injury attorneys, Gerald Clark and Mark

4

: 00:00:13

Morris of Clark Law Firm, as they take

you behind the scenes of justice and civil

5

: 00:00:17

law, but first, a quick disclaimer, the

information shared on this podcast is

6

: 00:00:23

for general information purposes only.

7

: 00:00:26

Nothing on this site should be

taken as legal advice for any

8

: 00:00:29

individual case or situation.

9

: 00:00:32

This information is not intended

to create and does not constitute

10

: 00:00:36

an attorney client relationship.

11

: 00:00:41

everyone.

12

: 00:00:41

Welcome back to Jersey Justice.

13

: 00:00:43

Today, we're going to be talking about

the trial process and the role that a

14

: 00:00:46

jury plays in a trial in New Jersey.

15

: 00:00:49

And I'm here with Mark and Jerry, and

we're going to be talking about what

16

: 00:00:53

the role is of the jury, how the lawyers

actually go explaining their point of

17

: 00:00:58

view with evidence in the courtroom.

18

: 00:01:01

So let's see, I'm going to let you

guys pick who wants to get started

19

: 00:01:05

first and chime in on this one.

20

: 00:01:08

I'm happy to go.

21

: 00:01:08

I'll just do a little.

22

: 00:01:10

Little background on that.

23

: 00:01:11

So the question is, what is the role

of the jury in a trial in New Jersey?

24

: 00:01:15

It's kind of everything.

25

: 00:01:16

There's different times throughout

the trial where sometimes the idea

26

: 00:01:20

is like, who's, who's the focus on?

27

: 00:01:22

Sometimes the focus is on

the person who's testifying.

28

: 00:01:25

Sometimes the focus is on the

attorney giving the opening

29

: 00:01:28

statement or the closing.

30

: 00:01:29

But the whole idea of the focus that

we're talking about is the jury.

31

: 00:01:33

Because without the jury,

there's there's no case.

32

: 00:01:35

I think we've talked about

before our clients aren't

33

: 00:01:38

going to have their case heard.

34

: 00:01:39

We're not going to get to call ourselves

trial attorneys and go to trial if

35

: 00:01:43

people aren't showing up for jury duty

and then and then doing their job.

36

: 00:01:46

Occasionally, there's bench trials

in New Jersey where a judge will

37

: 00:01:50

decide the case, but it's pretty rare.

38

: 00:01:52

Typically, it's a jury panel

that's going to decide the case.

39

: 00:01:55

And I think what might be helpful

is just to have like an idea of what

40

: 00:01:59

the day to day would look like if you

get picked as a jury or as a juror.

41

: 00:02:03

A lot of times the judge will say

they want the jurors there at 8, 845.

42

: 00:02:08

Each day there's going to be

different things that happen.

43

: 00:02:10

Like a lot of times once you pick

the jury, say you pick a jury

44

: 00:02:12

in the morning, you probably do

opening statements in the afternoon.

45

: 00:02:16

Sometimes a judge might send

everyone home and then the next

46

: 00:02:19

day that the case will get going.

47

: 00:02:21

But the kind of schedule

for a juror is like 8 38 45.

48

: 00:02:24

You're at the courthouse and the

judge will tell you each day.

49

: 00:02:26

Everything's everything's different.

50

: 00:02:28

There's a mid morning break.

51

: 00:02:30

Usually that's 15, 20 minute break.

52

: 00:02:33

And then you break for lunch.

53

: 00:02:34

That's an hour.

54

: 00:02:35

It's 1230 to one.

55

: 00:02:36

It's another break in the afternoon.

56

: 00:02:38

Then whenever everything's

done, that's a, that's it.

57

: 00:02:40

That's kind of the day.

58

: 00:02:41

And then you come back

and you do it again.

59

: 00:02:42

A lot of cases, if it's like a

standard auto, that it's probably

60

: 00:02:47

a three, maybe a four day trial,

anywhere from two to four days.

61

: 00:02:51

Bigger cases like construction

cases, things like that.

62

: 00:02:54

Jerry just finished one up that I

think was probably four plus weeks.

63

: 00:02:58

Jerry and I have done a construction

case that was almost, yeah,

64

: 00:03:01

that was almost two months.

65

: 00:03:03

It all depends on the nature of the case.

66

: 00:03:05

But that's just kind of because we talk

about how important jurors, juries are and

67

: 00:03:09

how the jury system works and how we pick

a panel, but just like the day to day.

68

: 00:03:13

So I guess people know

what they're getting into.

69

: 00:03:15

It's it's not a horrible day.

70

: 00:03:17

It's 8 30 to 4 30.

71

: 00:03:18

Sometimes it's ending early.

72

: 00:03:21

But like I was saying before, what we

see is the jurors are tuned in like

73

: 00:03:25

they're following what's happening.

74

: 00:03:26

They're paying attention

to what's happening.

75

: 00:03:28

So getting those breaks to kind

of recharge and then come back.

76

: 00:03:31

It's great because the juries can't talk

about the case while it's happening.

77

: 00:03:35

They do kind of get the time to

refresh like behind the scenes, at

78

: 00:03:37

least the way that we try cases, like

every little 15 minute break we get.

79

: 00:03:42

It's rare.

80

: 00:03:42

It's almost, it's almost twisted to call

it like a break because all that is,

81

: 00:03:46

it's just time window you have to prep

for whatever is going to happen next.

82

: 00:03:50

So, like, I'll bring a peanut butter and

jelly sandwich and have 3 bites of it.

83

: 00:03:54

Over the hour break, we have because

you're prepping what's going to come next.

84

: 00:03:57

So that's just kind of a day to day.

85

: 00:03:59

I'm not sure if that's what

you're asking, but that's just

86

: 00:04:02

kind of what I wanted to convey.

87

: 00:04:03

Like, what, what a trial

actually, from a practical

88

: 00:04:06

standpoint looks like for a jury.

89

: 00:04:09

Yeah, thanks.

90

: 00:04:09

That's that's exactly what I was asking.

91

: 00:04:11

And I'm going to ask Jerry now, how

is evidence presented to the jury?

92

: 00:04:16

And trial.

93

: 00:04:17

So once the jury's sworn in, it all

depends on the, on the court schedule.

94

: 00:04:22

But once they swear in the jury, the

jury, they're now the official jurors.

95

: 00:04:26

And generally the, the court will

be like from 9:00 AM till about

96

: 00:04:30

four or nine to four 30, something

like that, sometimes nine to five.

97

: 00:04:34

And then I think.

98

: 00:04:35

There's between the start and lunch,

there's like a 15 minute break and

99

: 00:04:41

then there's an hour lunch and then

after lunch until the end of the

100

: 00:04:45

day, there's a I think it's another

15 minute break in the afternoon.

101

: 00:04:49

And during that time,

it's just packed with.

102

: 00:04:52

Information and legal stuff going

on and the biggest thing with

103

: 00:04:57

juries, the jury experience a lot

of times can be like the objections.

104

: 00:05:02

So the attorneys object and then they

run off to the judge to what's called the

105

: 00:05:05

sidebar, which is like the side of the.

106

: 00:05:07

Judge's bench and then they're whispering

over there about how to deal with an

107

: 00:05:11

objection so that the jury doesn't

hear the lawyers arguing Sometimes

108

: 00:05:15

those objections can go longer and

then then the judge will send the jury

109

: 00:05:19

into the jury room Okay, go back in

the jury room and then they argue out

110

: 00:05:23

in the opening court without the jury

there So that can be a big part of it.

111

: 00:05:28

But once the jury sworn You know,

it depends on the judge's schedule,

112

: 00:05:32

but then the judge may send the

jury home, come back the next day.

113

: 00:05:36

But sometime after the jury's sworn,

there'll be opening statements.

114

: 00:05:40

So in a civil case, the plaintiff

will talk to the jury first and

115

: 00:05:44

give their opening statement.

116

: 00:05:46

And that's like an overview of the

case and what the lawyer expects to

117

: 00:05:49

prove and what the defendant did wrong

and what you're asking the jury for

118

: 00:05:53

so they know what the case is about.

119

: 00:05:55

And then the defendant will

do an opening statement.

120

: 00:05:58

Um, kind of the same idea and then

after those opening statements, then the

121

: 00:06:02

evidence phase of the trial will start.

122

: 00:06:05

So the opening statements to the

juror is not considered evidence.

123

: 00:06:08

That's just argument.

124

: 00:06:10

And then you present the

evidence throughout the case.

125

: 00:06:12

You do it.

126

: 00:06:13

primarily through witnesses.

127

: 00:06:15

So witnesses will testify, and

then as witnesses testify, their

128

: 00:06:19

testimony is evidence, and then as

the witnesses testify, you'll offer

129

: 00:06:24

documents, videos, pictures, things

like that into evidence as well.

130

: 00:06:28

And when it's in evidence, basically what

that means is the jury can consider it.

131

: 00:06:33

So then at trials, so then you

go through and the plaintiff

132

: 00:06:36

will present their case first.

133

: 00:06:38

And then when the plaintiff

has done their case, then the

134

: 00:06:40

defendant will present their case.

135

: 00:06:42

While the plaintiff's presenting the

case, the defendant will be trying

136

: 00:06:45

to cut down the plaintiff's case to

cause confusion, to make arguments,

137

: 00:06:51

to make it complex, to make the

plaintiff's lawyer mess up and stumble.

138

: 00:06:55

That's all the different

things they'll be doing.

139

: 00:06:58

Not to necessarily have the truth come

out in front of the jury, but More often

140

: 00:07:03

in our experience to hide the truth from

the jury, because if the jury were to

141

: 00:07:06

hear the truth over these objections,

and then they would likely rule for the

142

: 00:07:12

plaintiff in our experience, which is why

the defense is always trying to cut us

143

: 00:07:17

down, cut the case down, make it complex,

confuse the jury, because confused

144

: 00:07:22

juries are less likely to find the truth.

145

: 00:07:24

For the plaintiff make it hard

for the plaintiff's attorney.

146

: 00:07:28

If there's a new attorney, they'll

throw out objections just to try to

147

: 00:07:31

throw them off again, not to necessarily

find the truth, but to hide the truth.

148

: 00:07:36

So then after the plaintiff's case

goes, then the defendants will go

149

: 00:07:40

and they'll present their case.

150

: 00:07:42

And then at the end of that, there'll

be closing arguments, which is similar

151

: 00:07:47

to openings, but then the lawyers will

kind of argue about what the evidence

152

: 00:07:50

they think has shown and ask the

jury to rule in their favor and why.

153

: 00:07:56

And then after that evidence is

presented, then the jury goes into

154

: 00:07:59

a jury room and decides the case.

155

: 00:08:01

Um, but before they do that, the judge

will give them a long instruction.

156

: 00:08:05

Sometimes it takes about 20 minutes,

sometimes 45 minutes, sometimes an hour to

157

: 00:08:09

tell the jury what the instructions are.

158

: 00:08:11

And, and so that's it, and then the

jury goes in and decides the case, and

159

: 00:08:15

there's written questions they have to

answer, usually anywhere from four to ten

160

: 00:08:20

questions or so that have to be answered.

161

: 00:08:21

And depending on how they answer

those questions, it, it is then

162

: 00:08:25

determined who won the trial.

163

: 00:08:27

So that's how it, that's how it goes.

164

: 00:08:29

It can be a long process, it could

be as short as a couple days or

165

: 00:08:33

as long as a couple months or

longer, depending on the case.

166

: 00:08:37

Yeah, thanks for sharing that I'm gonna

dive a little bit deeper into that because

167

: 00:08:40

you said a lot of interesting things

that caught My eye one is about the

168

: 00:08:44

part of how let's say maybe the defense

will try to confuse Right the jury and

169

: 00:08:50

they'll try to put doubt in people's

mind and the confusion and to me That

170

: 00:08:54

makes me think of the word gaslighting

I feel like gaslighting is what they're

171

: 00:08:59

doing sometimes and if they're doing that

though Like, I'm gonna ask you guys a hard

172

: 00:09:03

question to think of an actual example.

173

: 00:09:06

Because let's say the defense is

gaslighting and they're putting doubt.

174

: 00:09:09

They're doing these psychological games

that they have to do in the courtroom.

175

: 00:09:13

How is it that when you identify

that, right, how are you going to

176

: 00:09:17

counteract with that to get the

jury back on track to make them

177

: 00:09:21

realize, hey, this is not reality.

178

: 00:09:23

This is only a perception.

179

: 00:09:25

This is a picture that's being painted.

180

: 00:09:27

Well, what we do is that's funny.

181

: 00:09:30

I'm relatively young.

182

: 00:09:31

I'm in like my mid thirties and I hear

gaslighting and I still don't know a

183

: 00:09:34

hundred, a hundred percent know what

it means, but I think I have a decent

184

: 00:09:38

idea based on how you explained it.

185

: 00:09:40

So you're saying when the defense is

trying to poke holes in our case and throw

186

: 00:09:43

this stuff out to confuse the jury and

all that, put it out, like into the ether.

187

: 00:09:48

At least I think Jerry probably

would have a similar response.

188

: 00:09:50

That's why I don't mind jumping

in is we would address it head on.

189

: 00:09:54

If they're trying to say, Oh, maybe this

person had something before, and they're,

190

: 00:09:58

they're acting like it's from this crash,

and maybe they're just trying to defraud

191

: 00:10:02

the system, and they're, or they're,

they're not hurt that bad, and they're,

192

: 00:10:05

they're malingering just to try and get

more money, we would address that head

193

: 00:10:08

on, because we don't take cases where

people are fakers, liars, cheats, fraud,

194

: 00:10:13

like we don't, and we sure as heck don't

take them to trial and get up in front

195

: 00:10:16

of a jury and talk about people who are

really hurt and deserve to get a lot

196

: 00:10:20

of compensation for what's happened to

them if we don't believe in their cases.

197

: 00:10:23

Yes.

198

: 00:10:24

So we would address that head on and tell

the jury straight up either in probably

199

: 00:10:29

in closing or what, but like if our

client, if our client's a liar, a cheat,

200

: 00:10:33

a fraud, we would be the first people

to tell them to give them zero dollars.

201

: 00:10:37

Like to send them out of the courtroom

with 0 because a lot of times what the

202

: 00:10:41

defense does is they don't want to be,

they want to hide in the darkness and not

203

: 00:10:45

make it clear that they're trying to, I

guess, gaslight or say that our clients

204

: 00:10:49

may be a liar, a fake, a cheater or fraud.

205

: 00:10:52

So a lot of times they'll

use their experts.

206

: 00:10:53

Their expert will say things

like symptom magnification or the

207

: 00:10:57

objective findings don't comport

with the subjective complaints.

208

: 00:11:02

Things like that.

209

: 00:11:02

So if we're getting that, because

that that's the whole defense,

210

: 00:11:05

like a lot of the times it's

just to sit back and poke holes.

211

: 00:11:09

So something I was going to say while

Jerry was talking is a lot of times

212

: 00:11:12

the plaintiff's case will take, say,

75 to 80 percent of the trial, and then

213

: 00:11:17

20 percent of it will be the defense.

214

: 00:11:19

Just because it's our burden of proof, we

have to prove each element of our case.

215

: 00:11:23

So the defense will just sit back

and try and poke these holes and

216

: 00:11:26

the gaslight and do all that.

217

: 00:11:28

But I think the worst thing you can do

is just try and run and hide from it.

218

: 00:11:32

Like you have to just attack it head

on and a lot of time to if we know

219

: 00:11:35

there's potentially going to be either

an issue with the case, we just like

220

: 00:11:38

to put it out in the open early on.

221

: 00:11:39

We wouldn't want for the first time

the jury to hear about a potential

222

: 00:11:43

weakness in our case from the defense.

223

: 00:11:44

It's just so much of it is

credibility, both with the attorneys

224

: 00:11:48

and the clients and and all that.

225

: 00:11:50

And I think that's where the

evidence comes into play, right?

226

: 00:11:53

When there's evidence, you

can't argue with the evidence.

227

: 00:11:55

They can try to downplay it, but when

you're going to prepare for trial,

228

: 00:12:00

maybe, last question, what's some of

the most important things or one of the

229

: 00:12:03

most important things you do when you

walk into that prior to walking into

230

: 00:12:07

the courtroom to know that we are as

prepared as we can be for this trial?

231

: 00:12:12

Jerry?

232

: 00:12:13

Yeah, well, probably the most

important thing you can do.

233

: 00:12:17

When you go into a trial is to like you

indicated to be prepared to know the

234

: 00:12:21

file well to know the facts and it's

it's an unbelievable amount of work.

235

: 00:12:26

These cases to know that the facts and to

know the file, but equally important is to

236

: 00:12:31

just be truthful and genuine to the jury.

237

: 00:12:34

But you have to be, you have to be

considered as a reliable source of

238

: 00:12:38

information to the jury, not a gaslighter

and Over the course of a trial, a

239

: 00:12:44

lot of it depends on the judge too.

240

: 00:12:46

If you have eight jurors in the

box, you have a ninth juror, and

241

: 00:12:48

the ninth juror is the judge.

242

: 00:12:50

And you gotta convince the

judge too of your case as well.

243

: 00:12:53

Because if the judge doesn't believe in

your case, the judge is less likely to

244

: 00:12:56

rule in your favor on the things that the

judge has to rule on, those legal issues.

245

: 00:13:00

And the judge decides what evidence the

jury's allowed to hear, which is huge.

246

: 00:13:05

You could have a great piece of evidence.

247

: 00:13:07

If the judge doesn't allow it

in, it doesn't do you any good.

248

: 00:13:10

So you got to convince the

judge about your case too.

249

: 00:13:12

And you have to be, like I said, you have

to be a truthful, a reliable source of

250

: 00:13:16

information for the jury and the defense

is always going to try to cut you down.

251

: 00:13:21

The defense is going to try

to paint the lawyer out as.

252

: 00:13:24

Misrepresenting facts or lying or

a plaintiff's lawyer being like

253

: 00:13:28

a money hungry lawyer that's just

given a bunch of BS just to get money

254

: 00:13:33

as opposed to standing up for the

rights of someone that's been harmed,

255

: 00:13:36

usually by a company or corporation.

256

: 00:13:39

And always we're fighting

at trial, almost always.

257

: 00:13:43

Almost all the time, it's

always for fighting an insurance

258

: 00:13:46

company behind the scenes.

259

: 00:13:48

The insurance company's hiring the

lawyers, the insurance company's the one

260

: 00:13:51

that has to pay any verdict or settlement,

and the insurance company's the one

261

: 00:13:55

that's doing all this gaslighting stuff.

262

: 00:13:57

Even though the jury will never hear the

word insurance at trial, it's all about

263

: 00:14:01

insurance, and it's all about an insurance

company trying to protect its money.

264

: 00:14:06

Can, if I could just piggyback off that?

265

: 00:14:07

Because I'm shocked, like whenever

I talk to friends about cases, like

266

: 00:14:11

intelligent people that Do work not that

different from what I do and I'll be

267

: 00:14:16

explaining a case to him and they go.

268

: 00:14:17

So who who pays that?

269

: 00:14:18

Like where's where's the money

come from or who's responsible?

270

: 00:14:21

It's almost always insurance There's

insurance companies and that is like one

271

: 00:14:26

of the biggest kind of not Handicaps,

not the words, but we're hamstrung

272

: 00:14:30

because we can't tell the jury.

273

: 00:14:32

Hey, we're not suing this guy who was

driving that car We're suing his insurance

274

: 00:14:36

company We're not suing like this mom

and pop construction company or whatever.

275

: 00:14:40

They've got insurance.

276

: 00:14:41

They've got multimillion dollar

policies or huge insurance policies.

277

: 00:14:45

We can't talk about insurance to the

jury, but for people listening, whoever

278

: 00:14:49

at that, it's almost always insurance

money that we're going after just because

279

: 00:14:53

there's, I don't know, that's just how it

works out almost 9 percent of the time.

280

: 00:14:59

If not higher, it's insurance.

281

: 00:15:01

Yeah.

282

: 00:15:02

Thanks.

283

: 00:15:02

All right, you guys, this one's a wrap.

284

: 00:15:04

If you guys have questions in the

audience, you can send them to

285

: 00:15:07

questions at jerseyjusticepodcast.

286

: 00:15:09

com and we're happy to actually

answer them on the show.

287

: 00:15:12

We'll see you guys next time.

288

: 00:15:15

And there you have it, folks.

289

: 00:15:16

Another episode of Jersey Justice Podcast.

290

: 00:15:19

If you're loving what you're hearing,

it's time to hit that subscribe button

291

: 00:15:23

on Apple, YouTube, and Spotify podcasts.

292

: 00:15:26

And don't forget to

leave us a review online.

293

: 00:15:29

Share this podcast with your

friends and become their legal hero.

294

: 00:15:32

Dive into more episodes

at Jersey justice podcast.

295

: 00:15:36

com are Clark law and j.

296

: 00:15:39

com.

297

: 00:15:40

And check out our show

notes for more information.

298

: 00:15:43

If you're navigating legal issues and

need a guiding light, or just a phone

299

: 00:15:47

call away, call us at 1 877 841 8855.

300

: 00:15:53

Again, 1 877 841 8855.

301

: 00:15:57

Until next time, Jersey justice

warriors stay empowered and informed.

302

: 00:16:02

Transcription by